Shi'ism Is Not Islam

Please give your reasons why you have faith in the words of those people in youtube.

Mr. Non-Muslim alam mo na ba ang pagkakaiba ng Sunni at Shia.............................

harballah wrote:Mr. Non-Muslim alam mo na ba ang pagkakaiba ng Sunni at Shia.............................

Mr Harb Allah, Hindi po nasagot ang tanong ko.

RavlaM wrote:


Mr Harb Allah, Hindi po nasagot ang tanong ko.

Ano ba ang gusto mong isagot namin sa inyo, sino ba ang tinutukoy mo sa YOUTUBE.....nais lang naman namin malaman ninyo ang paniniwala ng Shia, mayroon pa bang iba bukod doon

RavlaM wrote:Please give your reasons why you have faith in the words of those people in youtube.

Actually not all people in youtube; only those personalities which are agreed by mainstream Islamic scholarship to be reliable.

Moreover, the video which I posted as an example is well known to be true practices of shi'ism. If you want to belie or refute it, feel free to do so.

Our/my purpose here is to make a distiction between Islam and the shi'ah cults because non-muslim people dont know about it and usually such and such is part of Islam but actually not; they saw it or read it from books.

Islam is based on the Quran and the authentic sunnah - anything not part of it is innovation in Islamic religion and all innovation in the religion of Islam leads to the hellfire as said by Prophet Muhammad pbuh.

"kullo bid'atin dhalala, wa kullo dhalalatin feyn-nar"


Thanks

Tanong ko lang po, ang mga taong nasa youtube ba ay may kapangyarihan magbigay ng interpretasyon sa quran?

RavlaM wrote:Tanong ko lang po, ang mga taong nasa youtube ba ay may kapangyarihan magbigay ng interpretasyon sa quran?

I think you have a little difficulty understanding English language my friend.

I already have answered your question in my last reply - please read with comprehension so we dont do repeating the same responses, okay?

This was my response, read it carefully and do some comprehension:

Actually not all people in youtube; only those personalities which are agreed by mainstream Islamic scholarship to be reliable.

Is that clear now?

Jewel wrote:

I think you have a little difficulty understanding English language my friend.

I already have answered your question in my last reply - please read with comprehension so we dont do repeating the same responses, okay?

This was my response, read it carefully and do some comprehension:



Is that clear now?

Is it true that only Mohammad has the right to interpret the Quran?

RavlaM wrote:Is it true that only Mohammad has the right to interpret the Quran?

Wrong. Any person has the right to and can interpret the Quran as long as it is in accordance to the interpretation of Prophet Muhammad as understood by his disciples because they are the ones who understood every context of every passage of the Quran.

Is that clear?

Jewel wrote:

Wrong. Any person has the right to and can interpret the Quran as long as it is in accordance to the interpretation of Prophet Muhammad as understood by his disciples because they are the ones who understood every context of every passage of the Quran.

Is that clear?

Ano ba yan kuya! sabi mo anybody could interpret the quran...as long as it is in accordance with the interpretation of Propet mohammad.....................................................eh di tama ng si mohammad lang ang may kapangyarihan mg interpret...

I can't believe that Shia is not Muslim. It is our current understanding that Shia is Islam.

Even Imams Ali and Hussein thought that Shia is true Islam, did they not?

I think Sunni vs. Shia is a story of the struggles between two factions of Islam. It is a bloody struggle, more hateful than the struggle between Islam and Christianity. In the end, the Sunnis won. And, as the saying goes, they who wins write history.

Ateo wrote:Even Imams Ali and Hussein thought that Shia is true Islam, did they not?

Authentic source please....I know this is 100% false I bet. Ateo can never give an authentic islamic source for this.

RavlaM wrote:Ano ba yan kuya! sabi mo anybody could interpret the quran...as long as it is in accordance with the interpretation of Propet mohammad.....................................................eh di tama ng si mohammad lang ang may kapangyarihan mg interpret...

Naku ang gulo kausap. Bisaya okay ka. kabalo man ko magbinisaya bro

Jewel wrote:

Authentic source please....I know this is 100% false I bet. Ateo can never give an authentic islamic source for this.

Jewel, you know that I can cite from Shiite sources. In my mind, those are authentic Islamic sources, as I consider both Sunni and Shia as Islam.

What happened in Karballah is a clear proof that the family of Mohammad did not support wholeheartedly Sunni Islam.

Ateo wrote:Jewel, you know that I can cite from Shiite sources. In my mind, those are authentic Islamic sources, as I consider both Sunni and Shia as Islam.

What happened in Karballah is a clear proof that the family of Mohammad did not support wholeheartedly Sunni Islam.

That's funny ateo because it would be like quoting a cult's ref as a proof against the mainstream - who would accept that?

Moreover, i would like to see the statement of Ali and Hussien r.a. which you said about shi'ism; I want to know how did they say that because the issue on shi'ism began after their demise - so how could they say something about this cult?

I would like to know what they said about this new kaaba in iraq, pilgrimage in iraq instead of makkah, and wounding themselves, and this infallibility of the imams.

I would like to see that even from the shi'ite webs.

Jewel wrote:

Naku ang gulo kausap. Bisaya okay ka. kabalo man ko magbinisaya bro

Mapapahiya ka lang sagutin ang tanong ko kaya binibisaya mo ko...di ako bisaya!
ang katotohanan ikaw yon.

RavlaM wrote:

Mapapahiya ka lang sagutin ang tanong ko kaya binibisaya mo ko...di ako bisaya!
ang katotohanan ikaw yon.

eh bakit di ka makaintindi ng simple english? kahit igorot ay nakakaintindi na ng english ngayon

Jewel wrote:

Wrong. Any person has the right to and can interpret the Quran as long as it is in accordance to the interpretation of Prophet Muhammad as understood by his disciples because they are the ones who understood every context of every passage of the Quran.

Is that clear?

Ano ka ba Jewel puro ka insulto kapag nababalandra ka.....
Tingnan mo pinost mo...any person has the right to interpret the quran...pero as long as it is in accordance with the interpretation of Mohammad.....malinaw na si Mohammad lang ang may kapangyarihan mg interpret ng quran......

Tigil na po kayo sa nangiinsulto.

RavlaM wrote:

Ano ka ba Jewel puro ka insulto kapag nababalandra ka.....
Tingnan mo pinost mo...any person has the right to interpret the quran...pero as long as it is in accordance with the interpretation of Mohammad.....malinaw na si Mohammad lang ang may kapangyarihan mg interpret ng quran......

Tigil na po kayo sa nangiinsulto.

Alam mo ba ang ibig sabihin ni kapatid na jewel, kapag ang interpretasyon ay taliwas sa interpretasyon ng propheta Muhammad (pbuh) ay hindi na po ito katanggap-tanggap, kaya nga ang sabi ni Imam Hanifah (rahimullah).

"When I say something contradicting the Book of Allaah the Exalted or what is narrated from the Messenger (sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam), then ignore my saying.

Ang sabi naman ni Imam Malik Ibn Abbas (rahimullah)

"Truly I am only a mortal: I make mistakes (sometimes) and I am correct (sometimes). Therefore, look into my opinions: all that agrees with the Book and the Sunnah, accept it; and all that does not agree with the Book and the Sunnah, ignore it."

Ang sabi naman ni Imam Shafi (rahimullah)

"If you find in my writings something different to the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam), then speak on the basis of the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam), and leave what I have said."

Ang sabi naman ni Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (rahimullah).

"Do not follow my opinion; neither follow the opinion of Malik, nor Shaafi'i, nor Awzaa'i, nor Thawri, but take from where they took."

Iyan din ang dahilan ni jewel kung bakit niya nasabi ang word na "as long as it is in accordance with the interpretation of Mohammad"............malinaw naba ravlam o kailangan pang itagalog natin ang word nila diyan.

Hay naku , dami mong sinabi eh ang kahulugan din eh si Mohammad lamang ang may karapatan mag interpret ng quran...analyze na lang kayo.

Kitam, wala ka talagang kuwentang kausap.

"When I say something contradicting the Book of Allaah the Exalted or what is narrated from the Messenger (sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam), then ignore my saying.

Ang sabi naman ni Imam Malik Ibn Abbas (rahimullah)

"Truly I am only a mortal: I make mistakes (sometimes) and I am correct (sometimes). Therefore, look into my opinions: all that agrees with the Book and the Sunnah, accept it; and all that does not agree with the Book and the Sunnah, ignore it."

Ang sabi naman ni Imam Shafi (rahimullah)

"If you find in my writings something different to the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam), then speak on the basis of the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam), and leave what I have said."

Ang sabi naman ni Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (rahimullah).

"Do not follow my opinion; neither follow the opinion of Malik, nor Shaafi'i, nor Awzaa'i, nor Thawri, but take from where they took."

Sana pag-aralan mong mabuti ang sinasabi ng mga Imam kasi ganyan din ang dahilan ni jewel.

hina talaga ang processor at RAM ng taong yan kuya harby, parang kahapon lang ipinanganak tapos nagmamarunong heheheh

nagtatanong tapos kapag hindi nya nagustuhan ang sagot mo sya rin ang sasagot sa tanong nya hehehe

sana tinanong nalang nya sarili nya hehehe

Jewel wrote:hina talaga ang processor at RAM ng taong yan kuya harby, parang kahapon lang ipinanganak tapos nagmamarunong heheheh

nagtatanong tapos kapag hindi nya nagustuhan ang sagot mo sya rin ang sasagot sa tanong nya hehehe

sana tinanong nalang nya sarili nya hehehe

Wala na tayong magagawa jewel sapagkat mayroon talagang taong ganyan, ang importante ay naipakita natin sa madlang people na nasa centrino ang processor natin hindi tulad ng iba diyan