Similar topics
Philippine Standard Time
Search
Latest topics
Social bookmarking
Bookmark and share the address of The New Public square on your social bookmarking website
Bookmark and share the address of The New Public Square Forum on your social bookmarking website
Who is online?
In total there are 4 users online :: 0 Registered, 0 Hidden and 4 Guests None
Most users ever online was 470 on Tue May 29, 2012 4:40 pm
FORUM TRANSLATOR
Forum Protection
Advertisement
My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
+16
sakundes
Gordon
miss_terry
mozzarella
Comb@tron
Jewel
korrill
Yidda
adanedhel
fredms3
harballah
element_115x
Esther
Ateo
MarcCatholic
Dhugz
20 posters
Page 3 of 8
Page 3 of 8 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Ateo wrote:I hope Yidda feels better soon.
In the meantime, pakibasa na lang ang poste ko sa kabilang BARM:
http://www.thebereans.net/forum2/showthread.php?p=849055#post849055
debate challenge:
http://www.thebereans.net/forum2/showthread.php?t=50802
how could you possibly go in a debate when you excommunicate each other permanently.
Yidda will log in there now to answer the debate challenge.
Esther- ..
- Posts : 514
Join date : 2010-07-16
Age : 36
Location : Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
No problem, if that was the only case.Esther wrote:this letter is from Yidda:
________________________________________________________________________________________________
I'm sorry to say that I must write in this thread again.
First the priest defended the doctrine and the stand of the "catholic faith in matter of morals" which we also defend in what ever forum we are.
Let's see:The atheist used insulting word against the priest, which the atheist presented as if he is innocent but in truth he is intentionally playing with words(Damaso) to insult catholiscism. The priest reacted.
Who's fault now? who is correct.
Ateo posted this:
I don't understand why you claimed that "abortion is legal in the Protestant world". There could be a risk in committing falsehood if your unintended message was to imply that abortion is not legal in the "Catholic world". From what I know, abortion is legal in Italy, in Spain, and in France, which are the traditional "Catholic world".
And Fr. Abe's response contained such tidbits as this:
THE PROBLEM WITH YOU IS THAT YOU DON'T HAVE A SINGLE AUTHORITY TO DECIDE FOR YOUR CHURCHES. THUS, DECISIONS ARE MADE INDEPENDENTLY BY EACH GROUP AND MANY OF THEM 'OFFICIALLY' EMBRACED ABORTION, CONTRACEPTION AND SAME-SEX MARRIAGE. INCLUDING BORN AGAIN GROUPS AND YOUR BELOVED BAPTIST CHURCHES. HA, HA, HA...
Ateo posted this, in return:
Oops, Father. As my name implies, I am in fact an atheist... a godless atheist, so like you I also think of the Protestants as, er, misguided. But in fairness to them, the Evangelical movement is progressing quite well in all Catholic countries, particularly in Latin America. In the entire Latin America, social progress is progressing rather well despite the Catholic Church's shrill protestations. Chile has just legalized its divorce (making the Philippines the only country in the entire planet not to have a legal divorce); and Argentina, of course, just legalized its same-sex marriages. Catholicism is retreating, Father.
And Fr. Abe's reply once again contained such interesting thoughts:
YOUR FELLOW ATHEISTS [IF YOU REALLY ARE] KILLED OUR MEMBERS AND BURNED OUR CHURCHES UNTIL RECENTLY THE PRIESTS IN MEXICO WERE PROHIBITED TO WEAR EVEN THEIR COSSACK AND CLERICAL COLLAR. That is how nice atheists are. They are so kind as to murder the believers of God.
YOUR SO CALLED SOCIAL PROGRESS IS ACTUALLY SUCCUMBING TO THE STUPIDITIES OF COMMUNISTS WHO ARE ATHEISTS LIKE YOU. Now, the biggest Catholic nation on earth Brazil is preparing to host both the WORLD CUP 2014 and the SUMMER OLYMPICS 2016. She got the Olympic slot by defeating Chicago which was personally promoted by Mr. and Mrs. Barrack-Michelle Obama.
But even the, Ateo still responded as such:
No, Father Abe, hindi po ako Berean. Teka, papaano mo nalaman na doon ako sa Berean site nanggagaling? Seguro myembro ka doon ano? Ikaw ba si Roman_Cat o si Gordon? Curious!
But I am really an atheist even if you doubted it. The true test of an atheist is the so-called Luke12:10 test: reject tne Holy Spirit and you could not be pardoned even if you change your mind. Well, I therefore reject Him. That's it.
Btw, thanks for your interesting blogs and for your time in responding to my posts.
You ask who's at fault. Well, it's plain enough to see how your priest responded to simple queries and replies well before the word "Damaso" even surfaced. That comment of Ateo may have been untoward to a degree, but your priests reply did nothing to dispel it. On the contrary, his reply only served to confirm that view (Damaso).
Same with what you've done:
[/i]The atheist wants to broaden the issue by finding sympathy from members of Catholics muslim evangelicals atheist etc.. but in truth he also attacks their belief.
beware of evils plot.
Dear apologist this is not a matter of friendship, but faith. ~~~ Yidda
________________________________________________________________________________________________
disciple
may lagnat si Yidda.
honestly speaking , conversing with demons instead would be easier than to atheist, at least the demons flee whenever they see my SAINTLY face. esther
Even as you issue such a joke, you still display the same tendencies of a believer that atheists face on a regular basis: de-personalization, de-humanization.
Respect is not automatically gained through position or title. It is earned.
I have encountered many believers who gained my respect through their acts and the way they conduct themselves - how they truly live the life the bible describes. It is because of them that I have not chosen to abandon my search for proof of god.
Fr. Abe is most definitely not one of them. Your words make you dangerously close to being the same.
korrill- .
- Posts : 101
Join date : 2010-07-22
Age : 45
Location : Cavite, Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Why don't you just wait for Yidda's response on the old Barm between what Ateo believes
True for him: the Fr. Emeterio Barcelon,SJ article
And Yidda: Fr. Abe.
Personal opinions and emotions would not help , it does not matter too who's fault it is on their first dialogue.
Be guided by this link:
http://www.thebereans.net/forum2/showthread.php?t=50803
True for him: the Fr. Emeterio Barcelon,SJ article
And Yidda: Fr. Abe.
Personal opinions and emotions would not help , it does not matter too who's fault it is on their first dialogue.
Be guided by this link:
http://www.thebereans.net/forum2/showthread.php?t=50803
Esther- ..
- Posts : 514
Join date : 2010-07-16
Age : 36
Location : Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Esther, you missed entirely the main message of Korrill's post: that with your adhom posts, you are becoming dangerously like Padre Abe.
Yes, pls. tell Yidda that I'm willing to debate with her on Fr. Barcelon's stand: that there is no fixed position of the RCC on the RH issue. Barcelon is correct and I will add to that the fact that popes and councils throughout history had varied views about RH. Even the bishops during the Second Vatican Council had opposing views. The Bible clearly does not support the RH views. And while the RCC is trying to appear scientific with medical terminologies, science has lots of surprises for the RCC position.
These things will be out in a debate if Yidda agrees. I will prove that the RCC position is not biblical, not based on tradition and not scientific.
Yes, pls. tell Yidda that I'm willing to debate with her on Fr. Barcelon's stand: that there is no fixed position of the RCC on the RH issue. Barcelon is correct and I will add to that the fact that popes and councils throughout history had varied views about RH. Even the bishops during the Second Vatican Council had opposing views. The Bible clearly does not support the RH views. And while the RCC is trying to appear scientific with medical terminologies, science has lots of surprises for the RCC position.
These things will be out in a debate if Yidda agrees. I will prove that the RCC position is not biblical, not based on tradition and not scientific.
Ateo- ...
- Posts : 1019
Join date : 2010-03-29
Location : New York
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
No I did not read the entire because I don't think it is necessary to post the content of the dialogue and open it here again. Unless you want to talk it here again for the second time. Talking to your self and the evangelicals and others with no opposition.In that case I too will stop posting in this thread.
I don't think the debate would go well bet you and Yidda unless you know too the definitive teaching of the church Tradition Scripture Magisterium.
and by the way I want to post this one again it attracts korril. I don't know why he boldens it.
don't mind if I post this again:
honestly speaking , conversing with demons instead would be easier than to atheist, at least the demons flee whenever they see my SAINTLY face. esther
and atheist would not flee because they could not see Christ in me.
I don't think the debate would go well bet you and Yidda unless you know too the definitive teaching of the church Tradition Scripture Magisterium.
and by the way I want to post this one again it attracts korril. I don't know why he boldens it.
don't mind if I post this again:
honestly speaking , conversing with demons instead would be easier than to atheist, at least the demons flee whenever they see my SAINTLY face. esther
and atheist would not flee because they could not see Christ in me.
Esther- ..
- Posts : 514
Join date : 2010-07-16
Age : 36
Location : Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Esther wrote:...
I don't think the debate would go well bet you and Yidda unless you know too the definitive teaching of the church Tradition Scripture Magisterium.
...
You can assure Yidda that I do know the teaching of the RCC Magisterium on the issue and I am, in fact, continuing to study the RCC position on this important social issue in our country today.
Tell her that the RCC position is not new to me. Although, you claimed that Yidda is a Catholic theologian, ako naman ay di theologian level pero I was once best-in-religion awardee from kindergarten to high school, he he he.
At this point, with too many adhoms and to many threads to discuss, it is best for me and Yidda to face off in a debate thread where an impartial moderator will watch against adhoms and irrelevant arguments.
Ateo- ...
- Posts : 1019
Join date : 2010-03-29
Location : New York
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
may fever pa siya Kuya.
Esther- ..
- Posts : 514
Join date : 2010-07-16
Age : 36
Location : Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Ateo wrote:Esther, you missed entirely the main message of Korrill's post: that with your adhom posts, you are becoming dangerously like Padre Abe.
Yes, pls. tell Yidda that I'm willing to debate with her on Fr. Barcelon's stand: that there is no fixed position of the RCC on the RH issue. Barcelon is correct and I will add to that the fact that popes and councils throughout history had varied views about RH. Even the bishops during the Second Vatican Council had opposing views. The Bible clearly does not support the RH views. And while the RCC is trying to appear scientific with medical terminologies, science has lots of surprises for the RCC position.
These things will be out in a debate if Yidda agrees. I will prove that the RCC position is not biblical, not based on tradition and not scientific.
Sana matuloy ang debate at nais kung tingnan Ateo kung san mo hahalukayin yang sinasabi mong ipo-prove mong RCC position on RH is not biblical...which means biblical yang condom, IUD etc. etc.
Well, kahit hindi matuloy yang debate ay open tayo sa isyung yan biblically.
fredms3- .
- Posts : 982
Join date : 2010-07-22
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
If you cannot understand why an atheist would react negatively to such a statement, I doubt you'd be able to convince any of us that being a believer is the only way to being a better person. I suggest you try an learn more about what treatment atheists face from believers and to learn a little about what "sensitivity" means.Esther wrote:and by the way I want to post this one again it attracts korril. I don't know why he boldens it.
don't mind if I post this again:
honestly speaking , conversing with demons instead would be easier than to atheist, at least the demons flee whenever they see my SAINTLY face. esther
and atheist would not flee because they could not see Christ in me.
Peace.
korrill- .
- Posts : 101
Join date : 2010-07-22
Age : 45
Location : Cavite, Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Thanks for your interest, Fred.
For starter, Fred, try finding biblical support for the position that life and personhood begins at fertilization and that interrupting the development of the embryo is murder. Your Bible will surprise you my beloved friend.
Im waiting fir Yidda to get this debate started.
For starter, Fred, try finding biblical support for the position that life and personhood begins at fertilization and that interrupting the development of the embryo is murder. Your Bible will surprise you my beloved friend.
Im waiting fir Yidda to get this debate started.
Ateo- ...
- Posts : 1019
Join date : 2010-03-29
Location : New York
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
korrill wrote:
If you cannot understand why an atheist would react negatively to such a statement, I doubt you'd be able to convince any of us that being a believer is the only way to being a better person. I suggest you try an learn more about what treatment atheists face from believers and to learn a little about what "sensitivity" means.
Peace.
Actually, it hurts that Esther implies that I am worse than the demon. But Esther is not actually a close friend of mine. What hurt more are when close friends like Marc referring to me as 'naliligaw sa landas' and Dhugz assuming that i have lower morals just because i am an atheist.
Ateo- ...
- Posts : 1019
Join date : 2010-03-29
Location : New York
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
korrill wrote:
If you cannot understand why an atheist would react negatively to such a statement, I doubt you'd be able to convince any of us that being a believer is the only way to being a better person. I suggest you try an learn more about what treatment atheists face from believers and to learn a little about what "sensitivity" means.
Peace.
Oh I know you will react on anything we say, like vril so sensitive. How about you calling our dogma stupid is that right? Who would like to argue with you if your attitude is like that. whew sensitive.
Esther- ..
- Posts : 514
Join date : 2010-07-16
Age : 36
Location : Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Ateo wrote:
Actually, it hurts that Esther implies that I am worse than the demon. But Esther is not actually a close friend of mine. What hurt more are when close friends like Marc referring to me as 'naliligaw sa landas' and Dhugz assuming that i have lower morals just because i am an atheist.
wow Mr. Ateo I'm the only one left who is still willing to talk to you, anyway this is my last post in this thread. And how can you possibly make a deabate after many sees the way you treat the priest and now as If you are so professional in your challenge so kind and gentle. why is it you challenge Yidda when you ban each other .
Take care of korril and vril ha ha ha
bye
Marc is rigth 'naliligaw sa landas'
Esther- ..
- Posts : 514
Join date : 2010-07-16
Age : 36
Location : Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Ateo wrote:Thanks for your interest, Fred.
For starter, Fred, try finding biblical support for the position that life and personhood begins at fertilization and that interrupting the development of the embryo is murder. Your Bible will surprise you my beloved friend.
Im waiting fir Yidda to get this debate started.
Oks, i can already sense where your position would revolve. Maybe i or you will be surprised friend Ateo.
fredms3- .
- Posts : 982
Join date : 2010-07-22
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Once more, Esther: Who started the hate?Esther wrote:
Oh I know you will react on anything we say, like vril so sensitive. How about you calling our dogma stupid is that right? Who would like to argue with you if your attitude is like that. whew sensitive.
Based on your own post, I believe we already know the answer to that question:
That's why I find your attempt at turning the situation into your favor quite weak and pointless.Esther wrote:Personal opinions and emotions would not help , it does not matter too who's fault it is on their first dialogue.
Atheists react when we need to react. The exchange between Ateo and Fr. Abe is a perfect example of it - an atheist reacting after an un-called for attack from a believer. Funny thing is, as can plainly be seen in the post, an atheist shows restraint and more respect than the believers even when such things as name calling and accusations have been thrown against him.
It's also interesting to note how you consider an atheist reacting to being called evil, murderous, stupid, foolish, demon spawns and the likes as merely being "sensitive."
korrill- .
- Posts : 101
Join date : 2010-07-22
Age : 45
Location : Cavite, Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Ateo wrote:
Actually, it hurts that Esther implies that I am worse than the demon. But Esther is not actually a close friend of mine. What hurt more are when close friends like Marc referring to me as 'naliligaw sa landas' and Dhugz assuming that i have lower morals just because i am an atheist.
Does that imply that demons have higher morals than atheists, since demons believe in God???
element_115x- .
- Posts : 341
Join date : 2010-01-23
Location : Quezon City, Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Ateo wrote:
Actually, it hurts that Esther implies that I am worse than the demon. But Esther is not actually a close friend of mine. What hurt more are when close friends like Marc referring to me as 'naliligaw sa landas' and Dhugz assuming that i have lower morals just because i am an atheist.
Wala naman akong sinabing ganoon ah.......
Dhugz- .
- Posts : 770
Join date : 2010-03-10
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Woi. Saan yong naliligaw ng landas na sinabi ko? Hinahanap ko kaya. Please patingin baka naman hindi sa'yo yan or hindi ganoon ang nais kong sabihin. Friend kita noh.
MarcCatholic- ..
- Posts : 684
Join date : 2010-03-19
Age : 34
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
MarcCatholic wrote:Woi. Saan yong naliligaw ng landas na sinabi ko? Hinahanap ko kaya. Please patingin baka naman hindi sa'yo yan or hindi ganoon ang nais kong sabihin. Friend kita noh.
http://thesplendorofthechurch.blogspot.com/2010/07/exchange-with-atheist.html#comment-form
marccatholic said...
Maraming salamat po Fr. Abe. Na-touch po ako dahil nabasa ko ang aking message. ... Wag nyo po isipin na against ako sa inyo father ha? Katunayan nga po ay fan ninyo ako. Bilang tao naman po, may nakikita din akong hindi maganda sa pag ad hom nyo sa ating mga naliligaw na mga kapatid. ...
Ateo- ...
- Posts : 1019
Join date : 2010-03-29
Location : New York
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Ay dahil diyan nasaktan ka na? Di mo nagets Ateo? Naliligaw na kapatid. Nandyan na nga ang salitang kapatid e. Ang pinatutungkulan ko ay ang religious affiliation o in general ay ang kanyang paniniwala kung may Diyos ba o wala. Pati, ikaw lang ba tinutukoy ko diyan? Parang hindi nga ikaw ang pinakasumagi sa isip ko e. Honestly ang nasa isip ko diyan ay si Brother Eli. Walang halong biro. Tinatawag niya kasing mama. Sabi na e namaling akala ka lang. Tsk.
MarcCatholic- ..
- Posts : 684
Join date : 2010-03-19
Age : 34
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Kinikilig naman ako sa dalawang ito....ok na mag kiss and make up na kayo at baka hindi ako makapagpigil ay makasal este masakal ko pa kayong dalawa
fredms3- .
- Posts : 982
Join date : 2010-07-22
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Naliligaw ng landas in what way....??
element_115x- .
- Posts : 341
Join date : 2010-01-23
Location : Quezon City, Philippines
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Element, you know what I mean right? It's the most common and basic expression when a person refers someone being naliligaw in terms of religious belief, etc and I've laid my premise already. Subjective it is but you get my point right? No need to prove.
MarcCatholic- ..
- Posts : 684
Join date : 2010-03-19
Age : 34
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
It is not a "common and basic" expression. It is pejorative (judgmental) and commits the Catholic sin of triumphalism.
Saying somebody is "naliligaw" implies that there is only one correct way (your way) and that others don't know where they are going. It only sounds basic because your mind is used to that thinking. But one should question one's basic assumptions as well.
More neutral terms are: "may ibang paniniwala", "walang paniniwala sa Diyos" or "sa ibayong paniniwala".
I don't want to make a big issue out of it, but you challenged me to prove that you said it. Peace, Marc.
Saying somebody is "naliligaw" implies that there is only one correct way (your way) and that others don't know where they are going. It only sounds basic because your mind is used to that thinking. But one should question one's basic assumptions as well.
More neutral terms are: "may ibang paniniwala", "walang paniniwala sa Diyos" or "sa ibayong paniniwala".
I don't want to make a big issue out of it, but you challenged me to prove that you said it. Peace, Marc.
Ateo- ...
- Posts : 1019
Join date : 2010-03-29
Location : New York
Re: My exchange with a Catholic Priest----by Ateo
Bahala na nga po kayo. Wala naman akong nais sabihin diyang masama e. Ang sinasabi ko lang ay tungkol sa relihiyon ko. Sabi ko nga subjective e pero maaaring tama pa din naman ako kung ituturing ko talagang tanging tama lang ang Catholic Church. Di ko alam bakit naging big deal. Tama naman sinabi mo e na marahil masyado akong "nag-assume" siguro pero kaya lang naman naging isyu yan ay dahil sa maling akala. Never ko talagang ipinukol yan sa'yo, mainly. Tsaka, walang discrimination akong intention diyan. Salamat.
Last edited by MarcCatholic on Wed Oct 13, 2010 4:06 am; edited 1 time in total
MarcCatholic- ..
- Posts : 684
Join date : 2010-03-19
Age : 34
Page 3 of 8 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
Similar topics
» Filipino Catholic Priest in ancient Battle with Demons (Genuine Exorcists).
» Catholic Converts
» Famous Priest Resigned
» Catholic Converts
» Famous Priest Resigned
Page 3 of 8
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Sun Jan 08, 2017 2:42 am by Teng
» Survivor...
Wed Aug 31, 2016 1:00 pm by Esther
» Guys musta na kayo?
Fri May 10, 2013 8:51 am by RavlaM
» iNTRODUCTION
Thu Jan 24, 2013 6:52 pm by Comb@tron
» Lets talk about MARRIAGE
Thu Jan 24, 2013 6:49 pm by Comb@tron
» Para sa Muslim, Masama bang maging Pedopilyo?
Tue Jun 19, 2012 4:13 am by viruzol_007
» DEBATE with VANNIE...
Tue Jun 19, 2012 3:26 am by harballah
» DEATH PENALTY
Fri Mar 16, 2012 11:01 pm by RavlaM
» Ang katotohanan tungkol sa Iglesia ni Cristo na pekeng iglesia na tatag ni Manalo.
Wed Feb 29, 2012 7:57 pm by Lito
» Watch Impeachment trial Live Streaming: CJ CORONA
Thu Jan 19, 2012 4:02 pm by Disciple
» Si kapatid na Felix Manalo
Tue Nov 22, 2011 12:28 pm by Guest
» Ashampoo Burning Studio v10.0.15 Portable
Fri Nov 18, 2011 4:19 pm by Dhugz
» Atomix Virtual DJ Pro v7.0.5 Portable
Fri Nov 18, 2011 4:11 pm by Dhugz
» Constitutional Crisis?
Wed Nov 16, 2011 9:54 pm by Guest
» HOTSPOTSHIELD
Thu Nov 10, 2011 11:54 am by Disciple